Insights / How engagements work
How We Build A Brand Identity
The Logo Comes Last
Our brand identity process runs in four phases. The first three decide what the brand has to say. The fourth draws it. This page walks through each phase: what we do, what you do, and what comes out.
Why Brands End Up Not Fitting
Most identity projects start at the end. Someone needs a logo for a pitch deck, a website, or a trade show booth, so the first meeting is about fonts and colors. The company has not yet agreed on who it serves, where it sits on price, or what a customer should feel. Those questions still get answered. They get answered by accident, by whoever approves the logo.
The result is familiar. The mark looks fine and says nothing in particular. It resembles the competitors, because everyone looked at the same references. Each person in the room judged it on taste, so the strongest opinion won. A year later the company has outgrown it, or never grew into it.
We run the work in the other order. Company first, then brand, then visual preferences, then design. Each phase ends in a concrete output, and the next phase has to answer to it. By the time anyone sees a logo, the group already agrees on what the logo has to do.
- Week 1Phase 1Kickoff. First draft of the Foundation Document.
- Week 2Phases 1 and 2Brand Discovery Workshop.
- Week 3Phase 3Visual preferences session, in person.
- Week 4Phase 4First logo review, in grayscale.
- Week 4Phase 4Second review. Shape chosen, color narrowed.
- Week 7Phase 4Final logo package.
- Week 10DeliveryComplete brand package with the design system.
Company Discovery
Output: the Foundation Document
A brand describes a company. If the description of the company is vague, every later decision has nothing to check against. So the first phase has no design in it. We establish who the company is, who it serves, who it does not serve, and what makes it different, and we write it down.
What We Do
We ask the plain questions, listen, and draft. The Foundation Document starts at kickoff. We revise it after each session and keep the dated versions, so you can see what changed and when.
We also start a list of competitors from what you tell us, then research it further ourselves.
What You Do
Answer for the business. Expect to map your audience on a whiteboard: which customers you sell to, which you do not, and who inside each customer makes the buying decision.
Expect to argue about price position. It can take longer than anything else in the session.
What Comes Out
- Who the company is for, by segment and by buying role.
- Who it is not for, stated outright.
- What makes it different from the named competitors.
- A price position: low-cost or premium.
Foundation Document
- Background and Company Overview
- Product and Service Catalog
- Target Audiences
- Geographic Markets
- Unique Selling Points
- Marketing Goals
- Competitors
- Company Contact Information
- Brief Summary Profile
- Detailed Audience Profile
- Tailored Messaging Strategy
The price position shows why this phase comes first. A common first instinct is the middle: close to premium, a little cheaper, with more packed in. We push on that.
There are only two winners in business: the low-cost leader or the premium differentiator. Everything else is dead.Matt Marquart, HandBuiltBrands
The group works through both paths and picks one. It can stay a working assumption while you test it against your numbers. Either way, the rest of the brand work proceeds on it, and later choices get judged against it.
The phases overlap in practice. Audience and price questions often get settled in the first half of the Phase 2 workshop, before the brand exercises begin. The Foundation Document stays a living document after the project ends.
Brand Discovery
Output: brand attributes and brand feeling
Ask a founder to describe their brand and you usually get a product description. Features are easy to list. Character is hard to name. So we do not ask for it directly. We run a workshop built on comparison, where you point at brands you admire and say what, exactly, you admire.
What We Do
We send a one-page placemat about a week ahead. It has four exercises: North Star Brands, The Mash-Up, Brand Attributes, and Brand Feeling. In the room we facilitate and keep pushing past the first answer.
The same day, we write up a capture of the session in the placemat's format.
What You Do
Talk it out. Name brands you admire, in or out of your category, and say why. The why is the part we keep.
One rule holds throughout. You borrow attributes from other brands, never the brands themselves.
What Comes Out
- Three North Star brands, each kept for one borrowed attribute.
- One mash-up that sums up the brand in a line.
- Three to five brand attributes. Character traits, not features.
- Two lists: what the brand should feel like, and what it should not.
Filled in from Phase 1: the customers and the buying roles.
North Star Brands
What brands does this brand aspire to be like? In or out of category. Push past the first answer. What else, and why?
Brand Attributes
What 3-5 words capture the brand? Character traits, not features. Example of the format: "Honest. Operational. Direct."
The Mash-Up
If the brand were a mash-up of two people, things, or characters (living or dead, animate or inanimate), what would they be?
Brand Feeling
What do we want a customer to feel when they encounter the brand? What do we not want them to feel?
Carried in from Phase 1. There is no middle setting.
Two brands in the same field, set against each other. Saying which one you are closer to, and why, often produces an attribute.
Workshops do not run in order, and that is fine. An exercise can stall when asked head-on. The answer then tends to show up later, in a side conversation about something else. Our job is to hear it and write it down.
The attribute and feeling lists do not always get worked as formal exercises in the room either. When the material is all there in what people said, we distill it into the capture and bring it back to open the next session, where the group confirms or corrects it.
Visual Preferences
Output: creative direction for logo and color
People are poor at describing a logo they would like and quick to react to one they do not. This phase uses that. We put a wide field of existing brands, logo styles, and palettes in front of you and ask you to cross things off. What survives is the brief for the designers.
What We Do
We build a six-part visual brief from the Phase 2 attributes and print it. We frame the session as elimination. Nobody is picking a look to copy. You are reacting to attributes and saying what does and does not speak to the brand.
No logo concepts are shown yet.
What You Do
Send your own references ahead. In the session, mark up the printed pages by hand: circles, checks, and strike-throughs.
Say why each time. A strike-through with a reason is something a designer can use.
What Comes Out
- A logo treatment direction, such as wordmark or symbol.
- A type direction, and the styles that are out.
- A color direction: lead candidates, accents, and what is eliminated.
- The practical constraints any logo has to pass.
- 1Foundation: who the brand is
- 2Mood board: a 2x2 of reference brands
- 3Logo treatments
- 4Color palettes: near and far
- 5Competitive space
- 6What reads premium, what reads cheap
Each one kept for a named reason: a hidden detail, a sense of movement, a letter style.
Noted and left alone.
Each one dropped for a named reason. Whole categories can go at once.
Elimination is fast and it produces reasons. A color can be strong and still come off the list, because of what it means inside your product or because a competitor already owns it. The palette page of the brief shows competitors' palettes next to candidate ones for that reason.
The session ends with an assignment for us: develop logo concepts against this direction and send them ahead of the first review.
Design And Selection
Output: the identity and the brand package
Logo reviews go wrong in a predictable way. Someone reacts to a color, and the shape underneath never gets judged. We separate the two decisions. Shape and type come first, in grayscale. Color comes only after the shape is chosen.
What We Do
We design concepts against the Phase 3 direction and give each one a working name. We send them ahead with a recorded walkthrough, so the meeting is spent on reactions.
After each round we revise only the survivors. Once the logo is final, we build the logo package and the design system.
What You Do
Start with what to throw out, then name favorites. Say why. Ask for variations we did not show.
In the color round, bring in the people who will build with the palette every day and ask whether they can live in it.
What Comes Out
- One logo, chosen on shape first.
- A color palette and a type system.
- A logo package and brand guidelines.
- A design system your product team can build against.
Seven concepts shown. Three stay.
Small corrections to letter weight and spacing. Alternate versions the client asked to see.
One shape. Palettes cut down to two.
Color goes on last.
Grayscale does its job. Without color in the way, the group judges the shape itself, and picks one before anyone has an opinion about a palette.
Between rounds we make the small corrections that only matter once a concept is a real candidate: the balance of negative space inside a letter, the weight of one half of a word against the other. We also draw the variants you asked for, even the ones we doubt. Seeing a version is the quickest way to rule it in or out.
We show our own preferences and say which palettes our design team favors. You do not have to agree. When the client's pick and our pick differ, the client's pick goes forward.
Some questions can stay open past the logo. A favicon or a small supporting mark can be worked out after the main logo is final, in grayscale again, without holding up the package.
What Gets Delivered
A logo file is not much use to the people who have to build with it. A developer needs exact color values, type sizes, spacing, and components. So Phase 4 does not stop at the logo. We turn the identity into a working design system, and we hand over the reasoning along with the files.
The system goes to your product or web team so they can build real interfaces with it and flag what is missing.
Logo
Full color, black, and white. PNG at two sizes, plus vector files in PDF, EPS, and AI, in RGB and CMYK.
Color
A short palette. Every color has a named role and exact values.
Type
Two families with a clear division of labor. Freely available web fonts keep the system easy to deploy across web, product, and print.
Tokens
The brand as reusable values a developer can call by name.
Components
Building blocks made from the tokens.
Buttons, inputs, selects, checkboxes, switches, badges, tags, cards, stat cards, tabs, dialogs, toasts, tooltips, avatars, and icons.
Rules And Reasons
Brand guidelines for logo use, clear space, color, and fonts. A voice section, so the words match the look.
A written recap of the process: what was chosen at each step, and why.
| File | What It Is For |
|---|---|
| Brand Journey and Identity Recap | Why the brand looks the way it does. The process, the choices, and the reasons. |
| Foundation Document | The Phase 1 strategy record. It stays a living document. |
| Brand Guidelines | Logo versions, clear space, color palette, and fonts. |
| Design System Walkthrough | An interactive page that shows the system in use. |
| Design System Package | Tokens, components, and guidelines as files a developer can use. |
| Logo Package | Every logo file, raster and vector. |
What You Walk Away With
- A written record of who the company is. The Foundation Document outlasts the branding project. It is the reference for the marketing that follows.
- A few words and two lists. The attributes and the feels-like lists are short enough to remember and specific enough to settle an argument.
- A logo with reasons attached. Each choice traces to something your team said in an earlier phase. When someone asks why the logo looks the way it does, there is an answer on file.
- A system a product team can build with. Tokens and components, in files, ready to use.
- Decisions you made yourselves. We guide the workshops and draw the options. You throw things out and pick. That is why the brand fits.
See the brand identity project, where we guide your team through this process or run it for you. Questions about your own brand? Request a call with Matt.
Request a call More insights